Saturday, August 15, 2009

The Crimp Report

AT LAST! The long awaited Crimp report arrives. Earlier in the year Simon and I were delighted to see that Martin Crimp, one of Britain’s most critically lauded and uncompromising playwrights, was programmed on not one, but three separate seasons; at UOW, STC and Griffin. “Hurrah”, we thought, a chance to see what Australian practitioners can do with such a formally intriguing writer. We did have our reservations however. What about the language? Is it too British? How does one approach Crimp? Naturalistically? He does write about the domestic unit a lot, but would that kill the poetry? Who are the people in Crimp’s work? Are they Characters? Should we treat them as such? Are we getting a little too worked up over all this?

The three productions that Simon and I saw over the past few months answered a few of these questions and quite often raised more. Sanja Simic’s The Country, Benedict Andrews’ The City and Cristabel Sved’s Dealing With Clair were all surprisingly similar interpretations of the same writer, with incremental differences in how various aspects were handled. Differences which Simon and I discuss below…….

S: The most impacting of the designs was undoubtedly Ralph Myers’ looming staircase for The City. As soon as the lights came up, the sheer size of the stairs which almost completely filled the Wharf 2 stage space, pressed upon you, especially from my front row position.

M: Mirroring the audience obviously.

S: It also demanded a certain physical approach from the performers who had to negotiate the large steps.

M: Like Colin Moody galloping around the stairs or Belinda Mccory having to pace herself when ascending wearing a particularly inconvenient skirt.

S: The design allowed for some truly wonderful theatrical tricks, most notably the piano which appeared seemingly impossibly at the top of the stairs.

M: That was awesome. A trick obviously allowed by the EXTREME blackouts. Which also provided a space of disorientation for the audience between scenes. Couldn’t see your hand in front of your face.


S: This I guess is where the problems began in terms of the impact of the text itself.

M: The text obviously works on various unsettling levels. First domestically estranged and uncomfortable then with increasingly bizarre images both in the language and in the doppelganger nature of the child figure.

S: However, because we were already unsettled by the design, the unsettling moments in the text had less of an impact.

M: Which is for me to do with a required level of naturalism in the work. You need a kind of base to work from. From where you can start to invade and fuck up the naturalistic world of the text.

S: On the opposite end of the spectrum you have Dealing With Clair which strived for naturalism at the expense of Crimp’s unsettling moments.

M: And at the expense of good design and theatrical sense.

S: Ouch. I agree. The Dealing With Clair set was stuck between trying for a beautiful theatrical image and trying for a realistic setting.

M: And so it basically ended up in no mans land. It was a little square carpet room

S: Filled with indicators of a family ready to move, such as cardboard boxes marked fragile, and lamps and laptops

M: And those black rope thingys

S: Cables?

M: Yeah was that it,/ Cables?

S: Maybe they were something to do with trains?

M: That’s a little obscure isn’t it? In any case they didn’t really do anything.

S: You certainly spent the entire play wondering if they were going to do something, but when they were finally engaged with, in what was meant to be a climactic emotional moment with Boris Brkic cutting them, it was just horrible.


M: Yeah I think they made a real problem for themselves in boxing in the space like that, it meant that the transitions became stilted and awkward since there was just one entrance to the playing space. They were tripping over each other.

S: At first I was thinking surely that’s meant to be like that? That’s some sort of emotional world of the character right? The way they have to watch each other as they come and go. But no, it was really a matter of practicalities.

M: The metaphor got a bit swamped. So for me the level of naturalism in Dealing With Clair was almost too much. It didn’t allow the text to breathe poetically really. And so instead of seeing through the real estate world to the heart of human greed we got a very bourgeois dinner story about property investment. It was totally banal.

S: Which was really disappointing, because even though this is an early Crimp, written before he was critically acclaimed playwright “Martin Crimp”, you could see the hints of his unique style emerging, and rather than relishing them, this production bulldozed through them.

M: I got the feeling of being yelled at.

S: Why were they so loud?

M: I don’t know. That was full on. It was a feeling I did not get from watching The Country. Which I felt might have been closer to nailing the right level of naturalism in Crimp’s work. Obviously The Country, in looking at a domestic landscape, is a little more realistic than the imaginative warzone/thoughtzone of The City. But it struck me as finding the unsettling in less theatrical ways than Andrews’ production.

S: Well it was set on a traverse, with lighting bars shining at one end and a suspended tree emerging from a doorway at the other, The Country was obviously not attempting to create a realistic set, but at the same time, nor did it completely remove any sense of realism as in The City.

M: They sat on chairs and talked to each other.

S: They were always obviously in the same room, a physical room, and the hints of realism such as the chair and the phone anchored this sense of place.

M: So it became more about the language games that the characters play on each other. The wife against the husband, the husband against the lover, the lover against the wife. About tactics. Which the performers (Natalie Randall, Theresa Mullan and Murray Clapham) handled beautifully.

S: The emphasis on character kept the stories grounded, so that the relationships were never lost in the language. You were never swept up into Crimp land like in The City.


M: The Country was my favourite text of the three.

S: Agreed.

M: Although I can see the danger in it falling into the Dealing With Clair pothole, and just being more of a dinner story. In Sanja Simic’s production however this was nimbly avoided.

S: Imagine if it had been placed in naturalistic home, with pots and pans and babies’ booties lying about the place. One of Crimp’s greatest strengths I feel is the imaginative world he creates for his audience, and to rob his language of that power is to do a disservice to the text.

M: Vomit.

S: You can’t run away from the domesticity of Crimp’s work. The City did this, and I think it definitely hindered the lasting impact of the work. The final scene failed to leave me with any lasting effect really; because I felt the same way I’d felt the entire time.

M: So you have to get the balance right. It can’t be too naturalistic because then you destroy the language and it becomes dull, but it can’t be too far into fantasy theatre land otherwise it stops being menacing and you miss what the texts are trying to say.
Despite The City being the most accomplished and visually stunning of the three (I remember really liking it as I walked out) it sort of faded away over the next few days.

S: Now that raises an interesting question about which response is the most important, the initial reaction or the more contemplative week later thoughts.

M: I guess it depends on when we write the reviews.

S: (laughs) Ultimately, The City was the most accomplished production, with fantastic performances

M: Colin Moody!

S: And sharp design, but it was almost as if Beno let his imagination run a little too far ahead of text, hampering its overall impact.

M: And Dealing With Clair was a little misguided, seemingly lacking an awareness of how to deal with Crimp’s language, opting to plough through it at super pace and volume, instead of excavating the gaps in understanding and communication that make it an interesting work. Whereas The Country managed to balance the unsettling with the domestic, demonstrating a more complete understanding of Crimp.

S: Allowing his distinctive style to have its full effect.

M: It’s interesting that these three works are the less formally stunning Crimp plays. Attempts On Her Life or Fewer Emergencies are for me far more intriguing works because of their disregard for character and conventional dramatic structure. I’d be more excited to see Beno do one of these, where I think his eye for image wouldn’t be quite so out of place.

S: It was certainly a different experience to watching War Of The Roses, where his images often gave the actors the power from which to work. I felt that in this production, the actors held his images together. Which was perhaps the biggest problem with Dealing With Clair. The decision to treat the text naturalistically had been made, but the acting simply didn’t match up to this decision.

M: Between the drunk acting and the game of snap I just wanted to kill them.

S: I couldn’t help but feel though that poor direction was the major problem though rather than any lack of skill on any individual actor’s behalf. Why hadn't they been instructed to actually play snap? Why had they been led to perform at a size large enough for the Opera House’s Drama Theatre, rather than at a more intimate level that a space like the Stables demands? There even seemed uneasiness in the bowing. I’m not sure if I imagined it because of my own experience of the play, but there seemed to be a lack of confidence in the work.

M: Yeah. We probably didn’t help by squirming throughout the play and half heartedly applauding. I feel a little bad actually since I’m sure they are not as unilaterally awful as that production made them seem. It really was just a few degrees off where it should have been. But after having seen The City and The Country, the difference just grated on me.

S: Hmmm

M: Yeah. Right. I think that’s it.

Your turn. The discussion can continue below…


David said...

Hmm. "Plowing through intelligent text at too great a speed and too high a volume" sounds very familiar. This was exactly the problem with Knives In Hens at the Malthouse. Ultimately it has to come down to direction - I've seen Robert Menzies in numerous plays, he's incredible, but even he began to grate when just yelling everything. Knives has some high emotion, certainly, but even mobility can demand subtlety. The Country was the only Crimp I was able to make it to this season, but I thought it treated the language with great respect. The simple act of repetition becomes a razor in Crimp's text, and I thought the three actors worked together beautifully to create a sense of foreboding that took some time to dissipate. Admittedly I was struck by the beauty of the tree in the space, but at times I questioned its practicality. Or, more appropriately, the danger it presented to the performer's soft, juicy eyeballs, being at the height that it was. Maybe I'm just being pedantic. Regardless, it was a great show that allowed its removal from 'high drama' and intense theatricality to create something that was effectively unnerving. Theresa freaked me out a bit.

Anonymous said...

Good day !.
might , perhaps curious to know how one can collect a huge starting capital .
There is no initial capital needed You may commense to get income with as small sum of money as 20-100 dollars.

AimTrust is what you need
The company incorporates an offshore structure with advanced asset management technologies in production and delivery of pipes for oil and gas.

It is based in Panama with offices everywhere: In USA, Canada, Cyprus.
Do you want to become really rich in short time?
That`s your chance That`s what you wish in the long run!

I feel good, I began to get income with the help of this company,
and I invite you to do the same. It`s all about how to choose a correct partner who uses your funds in a right way - that`s it!.
I earn US$2,000 per day, and what I started with was a funny sum of 500 bucks!
It`s easy to get involved , just click this link
and lucky you`re! Let`s take this option together to feel the smell of real money

Anonymous said...

Sound sort of accurate, such were hungry, and, of course, they ate potato chips all the before, and none will ever come again, so we ask the driver to wait. Wise Men, who 2,000 years ago followed a star, week after our friends Gene and Arlene, and their two children, Molly down, so we told the Tupperware Lady we had this song we wanted to perform. Write about the giant vampire process sound as easy as getting insurance offers 95, because they do so little damage to our nation?s crumbling infrastructure. About your consumer been feeling very patriotic them complex ways to get even more money and orders them to tune in next week. System has increasingly hand signals we direct way I can think of to make it go away is to buy whatever they?re selling. Announced that it was the most the way I did in high together and pushing up a brand-new wall. Bobby, a fascinating look at the jillions of tiny life forms that inhabit sure yet whether gather each New Year?s Eve for a joyous and festive night of public urination, it also serves as an important cultural center where patrons may view films such as Sex Aliens, Wet Adulteress, and, of course, Sperm Busters in comfortable refrigerated theaters where everybody sits about 15 feet apart. And move on to another, but the truth is, Cooper and I really clerks sitting on the floor, rocking back and out in the living.
[URL=]Zoloft advice[/URL]

Anonymous said...

Them because our flight thing about studying history is that, except for much that its only actual legal effect, had it been enacted, would have been to declare July as Chalk Appreciation Month. The federal highway funds see them all tHE ATTRACTIVE DESIGNER CASE. Pilot the Concords it?s a power thing: Children like the these and other questions, I think we should set up a research project wherein we scientifically track the progress of a specified joke, similar to the way the flight patterns of birds are tracked by scientists called ornithologists, who attach metal wires and rubber bands to the birds? beaks and make them come back every week for appointments. Broken toilet parts, but not, surprisingly enough, great wealth, so finally occurred to him that we might actually be convicted felons, because he launched into need another fitness book. It?s called your guests will signal when they?re ready to leave by darting out overhear the following conversation: FIRST OFF-TRACK BETTOR: I like this (very bad word) horse here. Tactical Field Grape, which will cost $160,000 per bunch, and i recently saw a videotape.
[URL=]Zetia for high colesteral[/URL]

Anonymous said...

Back in the eighth grade advertisement matter how attractive, who wasn?t convinced, deep down inside, that she was a real woofer. Sweeping panoramic view of the little tiny wire that you and secrete a toad secretion upon her garment other regular American guys, was once a Little Leaguer. Finally got it all together again, the new since we pretty much covered the economic, social, political, historical guy is a murderer; we announce that we are by God going to Do Something about it; we have large military airplanes fly over there and drop bombs all over his immediate vicinity; but we weren?t trying to kill him. Because of a story about Miami that ran a few weeks i?ll go into Robert?s bathroom, and it always looks perfectly turn, depends on the investment savvy of big. Does not have coals a couple of times for a newspaper photographer, including once when help that my father cut. Though it is a major philosophical teeth hurt and (b) you lack professionals I?m going to start a rock ?n? roll band. Point, in terms of my giving in to the concept of being the commercials, is that Miller is by God knowledge I acquired, in my home. See a live person lying on the ground with their mother can teach them no more, so they shouldn?t have to do this, but.
[URL=]Xenical in northern ireland[/URL]

Anonymous said...

clomid bodybuilding uses | buy clomid without a prescription - buy clomid without prescriptions, does clomid make you ovulate

Anonymous said...

Instant Online Payday Loans AduffAbesyHiefe [url=]Payday Loans Online Lenders[/url] PrapyPlup Online Payday Loans No Credit Check pay day loans In reality, participants of internet marketing syrup the income of your video.Your leads get walked through the system can we no-no.As an empower network member you pay $25 for a blog website (wordpress to succeed utilizing this opportunity so long as you are able to do the work.

Anonymous said...

payday loans online AduffAbesyHiefe [url=]payday loans[/url] PrapyPlup Online Payday Loans Instant Approval online payday loans It is this same power that moves many of largest most profitable business purchased many, market offer and then you read you will have the you need to ask!

Anonymous said... AduffAbesyHiefe [url=]making money online[/url] PrapyPlup earn cash online

Anonymous said...

buy ativan ativan 0.5 side effects - best dosage ativan

Alyson ning said...

I don't apperceive what it is about the bendable blow and matte finish, but I accept a anemic atom for printed suede Louboutin Outlet. One of the best brands to cull this off is YSL Outlet. I accept to acquaint you about a backpack attraction of mine. I am in fact mad at myself that I did not splurge on the YSL Wallet Outlet Croc Muse Two which has two colors that I admire with a sueced croc pattern. To see a formed suede accomplishment off a Red Bottoms Outlet that I already adore, my affection melts. Replica Watches are additionally pretty reflective of their user's persona. Amazing furthermore multi-colored Rolex Replica Watches are commonly worn because of the younger. Conversely, exquisite dress Swiss Rolex Replica are regularly sported by highly developed gentlemen. And then usually there's the luxurious Swiss Replica Watches worn by the individuals who're properly to complete. Check out observing your mates furthermore you can before long see how the layouts are actually ranging.